There were days when I doubted we'd ever make it this far.

But is it ready for RFC status yet, you think? I believe there has been so many issues brought up lately that it should be pushed back and worked on for at least one more month. Do you disagree?

Posted by Asbjørn Ulsberg on 2007-03-14

Asbjørn,

I disagree. If you look carefully at the mailing list you will see that the 'issues' fall into two main categories:

1. Editorial nits ( things that, if changed, might make the spec easier to read or understand, but don't actually change the operation. )
2. James Snell

Posted by Joe on 2007-03-14

Now I disagree. You are mostly right, but there are two real issues, one of them raised by Elliotte and the other by you: the CSV content model of app:accept and the ordering of entries by app:edit rather than atom:updated.

Posted by Aristotle Pagaltzis on 2007-03-14

Aristotle,

True, those don't fit into my categorization, but I believe both of those are issues that can be fixed as part of Last Call.

Posted by Joe on 2007-03-14