The HTTP verb PUT under Apache Safe or Dangerous?

Joe Gregorio

"Is the HTTP verb PUT under Apache safe or dangerous?" This is a question I come across often, and have now run into it twice in the work on Atom. So is it safe? The answer is maybe.

Here are two such examples:

Using DELETE and PUT may be the "right thing to do" in an ideal world, but the fact of the matter is that a lot -- if not the vast majority -- of webservers do not allow these operations.

If anyone knows of a newer article describing HTTP PUT with apache, I would be very interested in seeing it. Because, due to my experience with PUT, you have to define a single PUTScript in httpd.conf, and if you PUT something to an apache server at the URI or something similar, apache passes all of the information to the PUTScript, not to anything else.

Both of the above quotes are from the Atom Wiki discussion of the use of PUT. A little digging reveals that the ApacheWeek article Publishing Pages with PUT is referenced most often when the danger of PUT is raised.

That ApacheWeek article does talk about the dangers of PUT and the cautions you need to follow when writing a script that does content publishing via PUT. That key part of that phrase is content publishing. That means that PUT is being used to upload arbitrary content to the server and the client is determining via the URI where the content should be stored. Now you can imagine how this might be dangerous, for example not correctly checking URI paths that include ../.. could let a malicious agent re-write your .bashrc.

Implementing a PUT script can be difficult and a security hazard in the context of content publishing, but that's the case because the client is choosing the target URI and the client could upload any content type. In the case of Web Services in general, and the AtomAPI in particular, PUT is used in a much narrower manner and avoids those potential security problems.

In the case of the AtomAPI PUT is only allowed on URIs that point to a pre-existing resource. The AtomAPI follows a general idiom for editing resources of doing a GET to retrieve the original XML, then a PUT on the same URI to upate that resource with the edited XML. No URIs are created by doing a PUT. PUT is not accepted on arbitrary URIs. This makes the use of PUT in the context of the AtomAPI just as safe as POST.

There are quite a few ways to configure Apache to process incoming requests. In particular it is possible to have a single script that handles all PUT requests below a chosen directory. This strategy, and all of the associated security concerns associated with it, are covered fully in the Publishing Pages with PUT.

When processing request with a CGI script all the PUT requests will come through. The verb is passed to the CGI program via the REQUEST_METHOD environment variable, and the program decides what to do with the content.

Using PUT propoerly has advantages in Web Service development. First, Apache lets you control security based on the verb using the Limit and LimitExcept directives, which let you restrict access controls based on the verb. Here is a sample of one of my .htaccess files that restricts the use of all verbs except GET to the CGI program Bulu.cgi.

<Files Bulu.cgi>
AuthType Basic
AuthName myrealm
AuthUserFile /path/to/my/password/file
  <LimitExcept GET>
  Require valid-user

In addition, the Script directive can be used to dispatch to a CGI program based on the verb used:

Script PUT /cgi-bin/put.cgi

The second advantage using PUT brings is clarity. Given the idiom of using GET/PUT in tandem on a URI to edit resources PUT clearly signals what the interface is doing.


ApacheWeek: Publishing Pages with PUT

RestEchoApiPutAndDelete: Discussion on the use of PUT and DELETE in the AtomAPI.

mod_actions: An Apache module for controlling dispatching based on verb or content-type.

Configuring your WWW server to understand the PUT method, from the W3Cs Amaya project documentation.

WebDAV is also something you may be interested in if you are looking for ways to publish your content using HTTP. WebDAV stands for "Web-based Distributed Authoring and Versioning". It is a set of extensions to the HTTP protocol which allows users to collaboratively edit and manage files on remote web servers. Mod_dav in an Apache module that implements WebDAV.

comments powered by Disqus