It's "Yay", because for important use cases JSON is dramatically better than XML. In particular, JSON shines as a programming language-independent representation of typical programming language data structures. This is an incredibly important use case and it would be hard to overstate how appallingly bad XML is for this. The fundamental problem is the mismatch between programming language data structures and the XML element/attribute data model of elements. This leaves the developer with three choices, all unappetising:
- live with an inconvenient element/attribute representation of the data;
- descend into XML Schema hell in the company of your favourite data binding tool;
- write reams of code to convert the XML into a convenient data structure.
I came to that same conclusion a while ago:
There are still plenty of use cases for 'documents' of XML, but APIs on the web is not one of them.